[He...blinks at her for the recoil she's made. She didn't hurt his feelings that badly, as he is the kind to contently disagree on things, but to have one of his favorite things compared to Mystery Jan's? It cuts pretty deep.]
It's okay. I didn't realize you were just teasing.
[A beat.]
It's probably their least popular, so I figured...
no subject
It's okay. I didn't realize you were just teasing.
[A beat.]
It's probably their least popular, so I figured...
[...that she hated it, too.]